Evaluation Of Compactive Effort On Asphaltic Concrete Mixtures Engineering Essay

Evaluation Of Compactive Effort On Asphaltic Concrete Mixtures Engineering Essay

Pavements can be classified as “ flexible ” and “ stiff ” . In common footings in the United States, the term “ stiff ” paving is used to sort have oning surfaces constructed from Portland cement concrete. A paving built from concrete is assumed to possess considerable flexural strength that will let it to act like a beam and let it to excel minor errors, which may happen in the base or subgrade on which it rests, therefore the term rigid. Similarly, a concrete base that supports a brick or a block wall can be described as “ stiff ” .

A “ flexible ” paving is termed as a construction that sustains close contact with and distributes tonss to the subgrade and relies on sum interlock, atom clash and coherence for stableness. So, traditional flexible paving includes preponderantly of series of farinaceous beds covered by a comparatively thin high-performance asphalt have oning surface. Normally, the most valuable stuffs are near the surface. However, certain pavings with a thick bed of bitumen or holding base classs treated with asphalt, cement or lime-fly ash will be given to act like classical stiff pavings. But, for convenience these sorts of paving are treated as flexible for the easiness of design intents.

A flexible paving consists of the undermentioned cardinal elements: have oning class, base, sub-base and subgrade. A typical illustration of a flexible paving is shown in figure 1 below. “ Hot-Mix Asphalt ” as the name says is a type of bitumen for which the predominant factor is temperature. During the readying of HMA mixtures, great consideration is given to temperature. Performance of the bitumen is straight relative to temperature. Asphalt has been used as a building stuff since the earliest yearss of civilisation. The Table 1 below comparisons flexible to stiff paving.





Last for 20 old ages

Last for more than 40 old ages


High cost and agenda care

More economic care, no agenda


Cheap and easy to acquire the stuff

Material deficit job ever occurs


Low initial cost

Higher initial cost


Easy to upgrade / phase building

Can non upgrade / no phase building


Ruting and chuckholes may happen

Free from rutting, chuckholes and corrugation


Less economic for the long continuance

More economical for the long continuance


Can be used one time ready

Traffic perturbation, delay for maximal strength ( 28 yearss )

Table 1. Comparison of flexible and stiff pavings ( Beginning: Haron, 2004 )

The first recorded usage of asphalt as a route constructing stuff was in Babylon around 625 B.C. , under the reign of King Naboppolassar. From the publication of the National Asphalt Pavement Association ( NAPA ) in 1992, the writer of the book “ History of Hot Mix Asphalt ” Hugh Gillespie stated that “ an lettering on a brick of records the Paving of Procession Street in Babylon, which led from his castle to the north wall of the metropolis, ‘with asphalt and burned brick ‘ ” . The word asphalt comes from the word “ asphaltos ” , intending “ secure ” . The Romans changed the word to “ asphaltus ” and used it to seal their baths, reservoirs and aqueducts.

However, it took rather some clip before asphalt could be efficaciously used as paving stuff. The Americans and the Europeans are considered to be the innovators of pavement building. Englishman, John Metclaf, constructed the 180 stat mis of Yorkshire roads. Thomas Telford, built around 900 stat mis of roads in Scotland during the old ages 1803 to 1821. He established a method consisting of utilizing broken rocks laid to a deepness harmonizing to weight and volume of traffic it would bear. The initial bituminous mixtures produced in the United States were for pavements, crossings and roads in the late 1860s. Subsequently on proper mix design methods were developed which created a antic revolution is our present transit system.


1.2 Background

Compaction is one of the most of import factors impacting the public presentation of a paving. Pavements are technically designed to prolong traffic lading. It can be referred to as a low responsibility, a medium responsibility or a heavy responsibility paving depending on the traffic volume. Normally, the higher the burden on a paving, the stronger it has to be. In the research lab, the figure of blows to which a specimen is subjected to is a reproduction of the existent field scenario. Compaction in paving is largely done to increase the strength, lower the squeezability and cut down the permeableness of the paving by rearranging its cloths. The cloths are forced into a denser constellation due to the mechanical force exerted.

Compaction has been done over the past centuries in most of the building undertakings. Compaction is done in order to hold a sounder surface to work with. Normally, compression is a procedure involved in the early phases for illustration, the constitution of platforms before the building of edifices. A good compression implies a good bearing capacity of the implicit in stuff. Compaction is regarded as the factor which controls the denseness of a paving. An addition in compression causes an addition in the maximal dry denseness of the subgrade. A paving is stronger if compacted with high tensile strength, therefore increasing its majority denseness.

Normally, compression of paving is done by large machineries viz. vibratory rollers, pneumatic rollers and steel wheeled rollers. These rollers are usually denoted harmonizing to their tunnage. The tunnage is an indicant of the compactive attempt being used. Pavement compression on site normally demands great supervising and truth. Nowadays, due to the increasing demand of traffic, flexible roads have to be more convenient and most significantly more efficaciously designed. Due to the advancement of engineering, there is assortment of machines being used to compact pavings. Figure 2 below illustrates a ego propelled pneumatic-tired roller which is really popular for route building undertakings. Pneumatic rollers provide a really much knit surface by working aggregative atoms together. They will instantly supply a more unvarying denseness that normally develops after vehicular traffic has used the asphalt surface for some clip. The contact force per unit area exerted by a pneumatic-tired compactor depends on the ply evaluation, the tyre size, the wheel burden and the tyre rising prices force per unit area.

Presents, the tendency is more towards vibratory rollers which provide a centrifugal force of up to 209 kN and quivers of up to 3,000 per min. Rolling processs vary with the belongingss of the mixture, the thickness of bed and other factors. In modern pattern, turn overing is divided into three stages, which follow closely behind one another viz. initial or breakdown peal, intermediate peal and finish peal. The dislocation and intermediate stages provide the needful denseness and the concluding peal gives the needed concluding smoothness. A process used by most organisations calls for the usage of three-wheel or tandem rollers for dislocation, pneumatic-tired rollers for intermediate peal and tandem rollers for finish peal. Figure 3 shows a three-axle tandem roller being used in compression of a flexible paving.

For a good public presentation of asphalt, the right sum of compression is needed. Compaction can non be done merely blindly. Normally, specifications and criterions are here to follow depending on the nature of the work. Previous surveies, more specifically from Bell et Al ( 1984 ) proved that excessively high compression can cut down the paving lastingness and do the fatigue status. Fatigue clefts are incorporated as consequence of inordinate bending of the pavement surface. The asphalt will neglect if subjected to repetitive or excessive bending from vehicular traffic. It is rather common on roads to see clefts at peculiar locations giving an indicant that inordinate burden was imposed to those locations. In the hot-mix asphalt design, the purpose is to compact a given volume of asphalt into a smaller volume. This undertaking is done by using a given burden to the specimen, therefore extinguishing most of the air nothingnesss. By making so, the denseness ( ratio of weight to volume ) of the mixture is increased. The consequence of the compactive attempts on HMA public presentation was analyzed and recommendations were made.


1.3 Problem statement

In Malaysia, the chief governmental organic structure responsible for route development and building is Jabatan Kerja Raya ( JKR ) . There has been a prompt enlargement of the route web in Malaysia for the last 20 old ages. The papers which is followed for route building is the Standard Specification for Road Works, JKR/SPJ/1988. Most of the federal roads in Malaysia are flexible pavings. Flexible pavings in Malaysia are designed for a life anticipation of 10 to fifteen old ages. However, as everything which is man-made is non perfect, pavings besides are susceptible to impairment due to uninterrupted and insistent heavy burden. All Civil Engineering substructures have to be maintained, flexible pavings besides need changeless monitoring and care.

Pell ( 1987 ) stated that increasing the per centum of bitumen increases the lastingness of a paving. The account proposed by Pell to back up his statement is that this is due to the midst asphalt movie which does non age every bit quickly as thin 1s do. Harmonizing to AASHTO Test method T425, 75 blows compactive attempt is used to obtain greater public presentation of asphaltic concrete mixtures. 75 blows give a higher denseness, which is really important in pavement building. The grounds to hold a good compression are to forestall farther compaction, to supply shear strength or opposition to rutting, to guarantee the mixture is rainproof and to forestall inordinate oxidization of the binder.

Furthermore, compression is done to cut down the air nothingnesss and increase the stableness of the mixture. But, it is rather ambitious to obtain the needed denseness as asphalt content is reduced. This has the consequence to cut down the lastingness of the paving in the long term. JKR uses 75 blows as compactive attempt for design mix to acquire the optimal asphalt content and it is eminently known that the higher compactive attempt gives lower optimal bitumen content.

1.4 Aims

The chief aims of this survey are:

To look into the public presentation of asphaltic concrete mixtures subjected to two different compactive attempts, 50 and 75 blows.

To measure the possibility of utilizing a lower compactive attempt, 50 blow, for pavement building.

1.5 Scope of survey

This survey focused chiefly on the effects of the fluctuation of the compactive attempt on hot mix asphaltic mixtures. The survey involved vigorous research lab plants for a period of two and half months. The trials performed were harmonizing to specified guidelines. The consequence of utilizing 50 blows and 75 blows as compactive attempts in the mix designs were chosen to be the chief standards to analyse. This was done to supply variableness in the consequences. The type of mix used was ACW14 for both the two different compactive attempts. The full experiment was conducted at the Civil Engineering Mixing Lab at the University of Nottingham Malaysia Campus. Data collected from the research lab plants were collected and analyzed consequently. The trial processs and consequences were presented in the undertaking study.

1.6 The Marshall Mix Design Method

The Marshall Mix Design Method is the most popular and normally used method sing pavement building. The Marshall Method was introduced by Bruce Marshall, an employee of the Mississipi Highway Department ( Goetz, 1989 ) . The United States Army Corps of Engineers are considered to be the innovators of the Marshall Method. The First execution of the trial was around 1939. Then, the U.S Army refined the Marshall procedure. The chief aim of the Marshall Method is to find the optimal asphalt content and to associate the experimental consequences to field demands peculiarly harmonizing to optimal denseness and the air nothingnesss content. The of import characteristics in the Marshall trial are density-void analysis and the stableness flow trial of the compacted specimens. Chapter 2 discussed more on the old surveies refering the Marshall Mix Design procedure.

Chapter 2


2.1 Introduction

Pavement technology is a subdivision of Civil Engineering that applies technology techniques to plan and keep stiff and flexible pavings. Flexible pavings, as the name Tells, trades with stuffs compressed to a desired form and size. Compaction in asphaltic concrete mixtures plays a cardinal function in the right public presentation of a paving. This chapter will give an overview of old surveies carried out sing the influences of compression on pavement public presentation. Furthermore, the causes and effects that influence the belongingss of paving demand to be identified. The quality of paving could be increased by observing the causes of decreased pavement public presentation and the apprehension of the hurt effects.

Compaction is the procedure by which the volume of air in a HMA mixture is reduced through the application of external forces. The ejection of air enables the mix to busy a smaller infinite thereby increasing the unit weight or denseness of the mass. The compacted mixture should hold sufficient nothingnesss to let the asphalt cement to spread out and contract as temperature alterations without make fulling the nothingnesss ensuing in blushing. The nothingnesss should be high plenty to let for some subsequent traffic-induced compaction during the few old ages of service without the nothingness content falling below about 3-4 per centum for dense-graded mixtures. If the nothingness content in a dense-graded asphalt mixture drops below about 3 per centum, important lasting distortion can happen. However, for dense-graded mixtures, the pavement life is reduced about 10 per centum for each per centum addition in nothingnesss above 7 per centum, harmonizing to Linden, et Al.

The compression procedure is affected by the status of parturiency of the HMA being compacted. In the research lab, parturiency is provided by the sides and underside of the mold and the cock. Compaction energy in the research lab procedure can be calculated. However, in the field, parturiency is provided by the environing HMA stuff, the underlying bed and the compactor contact country in its zone of influence. The sum of compression energy put into field stuff can non be determined. However, its effectivity can be determined by mensurating the addition in denseness produced by the compression energy.

2.2 Factors impacting Compaction of HMA

There are legion factors impacting the compression of asphaltic concrete mixtures. To accomplish the coveted degree of compression, it is of import to place those cardinal 1s which have a greater impact on compression. Assorted surveies have been carried out to seek to happen those chief elements which influence effectual compression. Previous plants varied from a big scope. Aspects on about all the known factors more specifically related to the belongingss of bitumen and sum have been investigated.

For effectual compression to happen, the compactive forces exerted by the roller must transcend the forces defying compression within the mixture. The mixture opposition is a consequence of the combined consequence of the aggregative stage and the asphalt cement stage which fills the nothingnesss in the sums. An parallel for the aggregate-asphalt cement system is the soil-water system of dirt mechanics where the opposition to a normal force is described as:

I„ = I? sunburn o + degree Celsius


I„ = shearing opposition of the dirt ;

degree Celsiuss = coherence ;

I? = applied perpendicular emphasis ;

o = angle of internal clash due to the meshing opposition of the atoms.

In comparing the soil-water and sum asphalt cement system, one must instantly acknowledge that the cohesive forces for the asphalt mixture are much greater than that for the soil-water system. This is due to the fact that the syrupy opposition of the asphalt cement is much greater than the evident coherence between dirt and H2O.

The angle of internal clash additions with the angular shape of the atoms in the aggregative mass, i.e. , a mix made from libertine river crushed rock and sand has a lower angle of internal clash than a mix made from crushed aggregative mass. By and large, the higher the per centum of crushed atoms in an aggregative mass, the higher the angle of clash and the more hard it is to pack.

When liquid asphalt cement is added to an aggregative mass being compacted, the lubricating consequence of the liquid ab initio reduces the internal clash between aggregative atoms leting them to skid against each other into a denser constellation. However, at high asphalt contents, the asphalt-cement forces the sums apart and does non let the sums to be moved into a denser status.

The belongingss of the asphalt cement do non significantly affect the mass viscousness of the mixture. Since mass viscousness is the primary force defying compression, the sum factors which affect it are much more important than the asphalt cement belongingss. For compression, it appears that:

The nothingnesss factor should hold a minor consequence, since most mixtures are designed for about 4 percent nothingnesss ;

The filler-bitumen factor is rather of import, as it affects the mass viscousness of the matrix that surrounds the harsh sum atoms ;

The effectual atom size of the filler is of import since by and large the smaller the effectual diameter of the filler, the greater its mass viscousness ; and

The volume concentration of the harsh sum likely has the greatest possible consequence on mass viscousness ; particularly as the maximal size of the atom additions, since there is an attendant addition in the volume concentration of sum.

The shear rate is besides really of import and it is one factor over which the contractor has absolute control. Therefore, if the mass viscousness for a peculiar mixture is higher than normal, the contractor can cut down the velocity of the rollers in order to diminish the shear rate to bring forth shearing emphasiss high plenty to travel the sum into a heavy place. Of class, the contractor might be able to increase the weight of the roller to bring forth the same consequence.

2.3 Effectss of temperature and force per unit area on HMA compression

Compaction temperatures in the lab and the field have been a great topic of research for many decennaries ( Robert et al 1996 ) . Since the debut of the Super-pave volumetric mixture design process in the early 1990s ( Cominsky et al. 1994 ) , and the increased usage of polymer modified binders, a important focal point has been placed on the best method to choose commixture and compression temperature. DeSombre et Al. ( 1998 ) used the Super-pave gyratory compactor ( SGC ) to gauge the compression temperatures for mixtures prepared with non-modified viscousness graded binders. Khatri et Al. ( 2001 ) introduced the construct of zero shear viscousness ( ZSV ) for gauging the commixture and compression temperatures of mixtures prepared with polymer modified binders.

During the period of 2003 to 2005, Rodrigo Delgadillo and Hussain U. Bahia, from the Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, in the United States conducted a survey to lucubrate the effects of temperature and force per unit area on compression of HMA. Four different paving undertakings in Wisconsin were chosen with binder and mixture samples obtained from each undertaking. The binders and mixtures were tested at temperatures and emphasis conditions that replicated field conditions. The temperature ranged from 60 to 160 EsC and the force per unit area from 300 to 600 kPa. Consequences were analysed utilizing legion attacks to develop a standard for field compression temperatures that will specify the consequence the temperature and force per unit area sensible bounds for usage in the research lab and the field. The testing included usage of the SGC and the binders were tested utilizing a rotational viscosimeter and a dynamic shear rheometer ( DSR ) . The tabular array 2 below gives an overview of the four different undertakings which were considered for the survey.

Put option Scanned transcript of tabular array here from journal demoing overview of the undertakings