Land Acquisition In India History Essay

Land Acquisition In India History Essay


The procedure of Land acquisition has become one of the most common issues in the recent times as a major logjam ensuing in undertaking holds, cost over-run, concern concerns and even abandoning of undertakings by assorted companies. Arguments, differences and force have tarnished most of the authoritiess land acquisition trades for undertakings by assorted companies in India. Protests against agricultural land acquisition, disqualifying compensation or environmental harm associated with the acquisition are some of the widely quoted grounds for most of the protests.

Tata ‘s Nano undertaking in Singur ( West Bengal ) , Vedanta Resource ‘s undertaking in Orissa, Steel giant Posco ‘s undertaking in Orissa and Raigarh undertaking Jindal are some among the many illustrations where the full undertaking has been shelved due to the onerous procedure of land acquisition in our state. Through this article we try to discourse the assorted challenges faced by corporates and companies in land acquisition in India, its societal and concern deductions and the manner in front.

In most of the instances, the provincials who are less remunerated when their agricultural land which has been feeding them for decennaries have been taken off from them by force for assorted undertakings by the authorities. In some other instances the expostulations and protests are initiated by assorted political parties to derive political milage and procure their ballot Bankss by back uping the underprivileged.

Although the act ( Land Acquisition Act 1894 ) provides legality to get land for public intent by the authorities, many militants and experts are of the sentiment that a figure of undertakings, which really does n’t hold any public intent. Take the illustration of edifice SEZs ( Particular Economic Zones ) , where there were ictuss of land from its proprietors at extremely reduced rates, by misapplying the Act. They show by assorted illustrations that even after batch of promises, the rehabilitation of the displaced have non take topographic point decently. Harmonizing to them, at the terminal it is merely the underprivileged who pay brawny monetary value for the so called development.

One interesting fact is that India has the maximal figure of Particular Economic Zones in the universe inspite of extended protests against the ill-famed exercising of land-grabbing. Taking the illustration of Posco undertaking where the province authorities manipulated the land records to denote that no 1 occupied or of all time inhabited the disputed land, there are many inquiries that pop up in anyone ‘s head- Will the marginalised husbandmans get back what they lost of all time? Will they of all time be paid atleast their echt due sum? How will one take in to account the loses other than the pecuniary 1s? Where will this sort of ‘development ‘ lead us to? How can growing be achieved in a manner which does n’t ache a large piece of the society? What is the manner out? We shall look at the assorted instances that happened all over India to hold a better position of the job so that we can come up with an optimum solution.

Tata Nano at Singur

Tata motors announced in May 2006 to get down an car mill in Singur ( West Bengal ) to get down the production of Nano-the universe ‘s cheapest car. The West Bengal offered Tata Motors 5 different sites to construct its mill out of which Singur was chosen.

The Land Acquisition Act 1894 was meant to supply Government to get lands for Public intents. Why the Government came in between the land trade is one of the major inquiries we will discourse in the instance. The consent of the people was purportedly taken by the Government before the land was given off to the Tatas. All 9 meetings were held with the political party representatives & A ; the panchayets but non with th vitamin E Gram Sabhas.

Picture: Tapasi Malik ‘s female parent. Tapasi lost her life in the protest against Nano mill

The province authorities had a batch of secretiveness sing the undertaking. Even earlier political parties ( TMC ) were involved there were two instances filed under the Right to Information act demanding a transparence in the land trades which were handily ignored. No comprehensive rehabilitation was offered in the land trade. The issue of compensation to share-croppers and landless people has non been remotely resolved.

The manner Tatas have used the Government to derive subsidies over the old ages remains a controversial subject and forms one of the Southern Cross points of this instance. The political convulsion that emerged in West Bengal had the Opposition harping on one chief thing- undue sops offered to the Tatas & A ; justness non provided to the landholders & A ; the landless laborers.

Till 1980s the Tatas considered Government as a regulator, but one time Ratan Tata came in the helm of personal businesss things changed for them. Throughout history of the last few decennaries, Tata ‘s have ever been able to acquire meaty trades out of authorities. There has been heard and unheard protests all over the state against the use by authoritiess towards Tata ‘s with regard to land trades for assorted undertakings. Some of them other than Singur are

Chilka Shrimp cultivation ( 1991 )

Golapur and Kalinga Steel workss ( 1995, 2004 )

Sanad Automobile works ( 2008 )

There were batch of protests and guiltless lives have been affected in all the above undertakings. But surprisingly the Tatas have non returned land at any of these topographic points except Chilka. In West Bengal they have written to the Government for an extension of the rental of the land. Many people are of the sentiment that the Tata ‘s determination to go forth Singur is a well-planned strategic determination & A ; may incorporate more factors than that which meets the normal human oculus.

The Tatas have used the land difference in Singur smartly to their favor. The fabricating cost of the auto went down in the following twelvemonth due to diminish in steel monetary values. They bought excess clip to come out of recession. Gasoline monetary values came down. They took involvement free sedimentations from Nano purchasers which amounted to US $ 1 billion.

The works was smartly shifted to Gujarat where they were welcomed by both custodies to get down and offered land in Sunand.

Picture: Peoples demoing their protest by firing the image of Nano

Paradoxically, even after two old ages the Tata ‘s has non given back the land to the authorities because, as per the understanding the company has legal rights over the land for 90 old ages since it has been leased to them for that period. It is anyone ‘s conjecture that the mighty Tatas in no manner will give up the land until and unless boulder clay they feel they are sufficiently compensated for all the loss they have bared as a consequence of the protests and contentions. The authorities is besides in a incapacitated place.

Mamata Banerjee, so the leader of the protests and now the railroad curate, has programs to get down a manager mill at the disputed site. She plans to make so one time the authorities of West Bengal give back over four thousand estates of land taken from assorted unwilling husbandmans. There are besides around 50 sellers, who earlier signed rental understandings for the Nano Project, has now signed single understandings with the authorities. The rent per acre yearly for the sellers is Rs. 8000. Tata motors is yet to pay Rs. 5 crores for the 646 estates of land for a period of 5 old ages.

There has been a proposal from BHEL for puting up a medium graduated table power works at the site occupied by Nano mill. But, sing assorted issues and the cost benefit analysis, the company decided to trash the thought.

Navi Mumbai International Airport

I, as a occupant of Navi Mumbai for 17 old ages from 1992, came to cognize about this undertaking in 2002 from our local MLA. First it was notified that it would be a domestic airdrome providing largely to low cost air hoses and so acquire converted into a fully fledged 1.

On a political degree, negotiations sing a 2nd airdrome for Mumbai started in 1997. It has been 14 old ages since so and non an shred of building work has started at the site.

Figure: Location of the undertaking vis-a-vis the bing Santacruz/Sahar airdrome

An In Principle blessing dating July 2007 for the 2nd airdrome providing to Mumbai and located at Navi Mumbai, on a PPP ( public-private partnership ) footing was granted by the Civil Aviation ministry. Blessing from the Maharashtra province authorities was granted in 2008. At this clip CIDCO ( City & A ; Industrial Development Corporation of Maharashtra Limited ) the regional development bureau for Navi Mumbai was allotted this undertaking.

Legal & A ; Administrative apparatus

The undertaking proposal has to stay by 3 statute laws:

Environment Impact Assessment ( EIA ) Notification, 2006 ( The undertaking is in Category A/Activity 7a )

Environment ( Protection ) Act, 1986

Coastal Zone Regulation, 1991, 15th May 2009 amendments

The comprehensive environmental impact appraisal survey required for this undertaking was undertaken by Centre of Environment Science and Engineering, Indian Institute of Technology, Bombay. ( CESE, EIA 2007 )






Panvel Taluka, RaigadDist. , Maharashtra State.



18A°.58′.44.61 ” to 19A°.0′.57.16 ”



73A°.02′.54 ” to73A°.05′.39.61 ”


General Elevation

Coastal ( RL1.5mts. ) , Plain ( RL3.0mts ) Hills ( RL82mts. )





Soil type

Marine, Murum, Rocks



Temperature-Max.36A° Min.17A°

Rainfall 2000mm to2500mm

WindDirection-South-West inmonsoon & A ; RestofNorth-East, Humidity61-86 %


Present siteland


CIDCOownedandprivatelandtobeacquired for airportdevelopment.


Nearest Highwaies

SH54, NH4B, AamraMarg ( BoundaryofAirport site ) .


Nearest Rly.


Panvel 1.5kms. onCentral Rly./KonkanRly.

Khandeshwar-1km. suburbanRly.


Nearest Airport

35Kms.NorthSantacruz, Mumbai.




Panvel brook, Gadhi river, Talojariverand Ulweriverrunning along & A ; through the boundaryoftheairport.


Nearest Hill

Ulwehill -RL82Mts.withinthesite.



Elephantaat adistanceof13Kms.West



Zone-III asper IS: 1893 ( Part-I ) 2002.


After transporting out extended feasibleness surveies, merely 2 sites came out. The other viableoption was the Rewas-Mandva site, which was later rejected due to the enormous environmental catastrophe the undertaking would hold brought upon later.


A sum of 2054 hectares has been allotted for the full undertaking. This country comprises of the 1615 Hectares earmarked for the existent airdrome zone, while the remainder would be used for other infrastructural development.

Water Requirement

Provided via H2O supply brinies of CIDCO

Phase I

9 mld

Phase II

18 mld

Phase III

30 mld

Phase IV

39 mld

Power Supply Requirement5

Provided via province grid and DG sets in instance of failure

Phase I

30 MVA

Phase II

70 MVA

Phase III

150 MVA

Phase IV

190 MVA

Sewage Treatment Plant & A ; Solid waste intervention

Around 38 mld of sewerage which is expected to be generated, would be treated in a modern works based on SBR engineering. The attendant H2O would so be used for subsidiary intents in and around the airdrome for lavation of floors, flushing, spraying H2O on the route, irrigating vegetations, etc.

The Chaal works at Taloja would handle the solid waste ( ~40 metric tons daily ) generated, and non-biodegradable waste would be incinerated at the Municipal corporation installation.

Undertaking Cost5

Includes aeronautical and non-aeronautical activities

Phase I

` 4952 Crores

Phase II

` 2159 Crores

Phase III

` 1878 Crores

Phase IV

` 366 Crores

Land Status & A ; Settlement5

Merely 2 % of the private land has been acquired as off Jan 2011.

Since December 22, CIDCO has cleared 60 secret plans given to villagers under the rehabilitation strategy. Harmonizing to this strategy, villagers will acquire 12.5 per cent country of their acquired land at an option developed site, besides other signifiers of compensation

The article Navi Mumbai airdrome: rehab strategy additions impulse, Posted: Fri Jan 28 2011, 00:35 hour, Indian Express cites the followers:

“ Till now, we have given the missive of purpose to project affected households for around 786 secret plans as compensation. Of this, 60 secret plans were cleared since December 22 in an on-going particular thrust. This works out to around 43 hectares. We still have another 143 secret plans left to give out to households, ” said another CIDCO functionary. Many of the undertaking affected individuals of the first coevals are already dead. Some of the legal hurdlings involved includes placing the right inheritor of the PAPs who will acquire compensation.

CIDCO functionaries said that the proposal for geting extra land had already been sent to the province authorities and will be negotiated with the villagers. “ We are still in the procedure of negociating the footings for the new acquisition with the authorities, ” said Vishwas Patil, one of the representatives of the undertaking affected individuals, from the 10 small towns which is being acquired for the airdrome. Entire land earmarked for the airdrome undertaking is about 2,020 hectares ; 1,160 hectares is for the airdrome while the remainder is for environing substructure undertakings. “ Around 20 per cent of this entire land is yet to be acquired, ” said Satre.

This comes even as the CIDCO filed a request at the Bombay High Court to retain a secret plan of land which falls at the bosom of the Navi Mumbai undertaking -around 157 estates which which is owned by the Bilwalkar household. This land has been earmarked for one of the tracks of the 2nd airdrome. On Tuesday, the High Court directed the authorities to register the land records for this piece of land by February 1. “

It is clear from the above mentioning that the undertaking faces tonss of hurdle in land acquisition itself now that the Environment curate has agreed to give a spell in front in his departmental hiccough

Figure: This depicts the position of relocation and rehabilitation required for the undertaking

Environmental casualty?

Inspite of the so called green signal received by the undertaking form the environment ministry the undermentioned figure summarizes the environmental impact.

Figure: Environmental effects

Salboni Land Acquisition

The Allahabad High tribunal gave a landmark opinion on the issue of Land Acquisition in September 2010. The two-judge Bench observed, “ Throwing out villagers from their land and taking away their support and a manner of life is province sponsored terrorist act. ” The Bench was peculiarly critical about the manner land was acquired in UP & A ; Orissa. The Centre is now looking at an amendment of the Land Acquisition Act. An amendment of this colonial act is long required but the Centre & A ; the provinces have ne’er paid attentiveness to this. They have manipulated this act to their ain private additions.

The state is turning in every domain & A ; sing a batch of alterations. But unluckily the colonial Land Acquisition Act of 1894 has undergone small alterations. With the of all time increasing human population & A ; human ingestion the demand for land has gone up drastically. Unless certain major alterations are brought in the common adult male would ever be the victim of this “ State sponsored Terrorism ” . The amendment must redefine such footings as “ public intent ” , “ public involvement ” and “ public good ” . Under these caputs the State can acquire usurp land from any private proprietor. In October 2007, the Supreme Court had ruled against the cover usage of such looks by the State for the interest of geting private land. The tribunal laid down the parametric quantities that ought to regulate the acquisition of agricultural land for non-agricultural intents. The cardinal concerns are justness and equity. A commission was appointed by the Planning Commission to analyze these footings in 2008. The commission recommended that “ land apparently acquired in the public involvement should non be handed over to private entities. ”

A private company which acquires Land is supposed to plow back the money for public intents. The inquiry that is to be answered is that if a company utilises its net income merely to bring forth employment chances, can it be called a “ public intent ” ?

The mystifier centres on the theoretical account to be followed. It must be acceptable to husbandmans and investors. Farmers and villagers must hold the right to protect their land. Unfortunately this seldom happens.

The options are: Direct purchase from the husbandmans by the industrialists ; secondly the Government can get the land from the husbandmans & A ; give it to the industrialist. ; The 3rd signifier is for the industrialist to get 70 per cent of the needed land and so the authorities will get and supply the staying 30 per cent. The theoretical account that may yet work is direct purchase of non-agricultural land from landholders, avoiding mediators. Transparency must be maintained and should the landholders be aggrieved, they will be able move tribunal.

In 2008, the Jindal group had planned to get 6000 estates of non-agricultural land for their steel works straight from the landholders by paying compensation and assigning portions of the company. The works is scheduled to come up in Salboni, West Bengal. This Salboni theoretical account has been hailed by industrialists and initiates as one of the best bundles offered to displaced households.

JSW Steel inked a memoranda of understanding ( MoA ) with the State Government for puting up a 10-million metric tons per annum ( mtpa ) steel works at Salboni near Kharagpur at an investing of Rs 35,000 crore. JSW Steel has proposed to put up this 10-mtpa steel works in stages in the following 12 old ages. The first stage, with a capacity of 3 mtpa and an investing of Rs 10,000 crore, was scheduled to be ready within 2011.

The Bengal Chamber of Commerce hailed Jindal ‘s Salboni compensation bundle as a “ alone trendsetting sort ” & A ; said that it represented “ inclusive growing ” . The chamber commented “ Basically, this theoretical account is representative of inclusive growing, in so far as it makes the landholders from whom land is being purchased as stakeholders ” .

Mr. Sajjan Jindal announced that Jindal Steel would offer free portions to 741 husbandman households, whose land would hold to be acquired for the proposed Rs. 35,000 crore mega steel works at Salboni in West Midnapore territory of West Bengal. While 50 per cent of the compensation would be given in check, the balance would be deposited as an rente policy collectible monthly boulder clay decease of the annuitant. JSW besides promised to supply occupation to one member of the household following suited preparation. The company would besides supply equity harmonizing to the rating of the land acquired. The equity would be in the land giver ‘s name and kept in a Trust signifier with the District Magistrate. At the terminal of the lock-in period, the land giver would hold the option of encashment of his portions or keeping

The JSW group successfully managed to get land from Salboni without any major hiccoughs. The Jindals flaunt their Salboni theoretical account and program to retroflex it elsewhere. On August 27th 2008 Sajjan Jindal announced in Kolkata “ We want to give portions to all who give up land for our undertakings, irrespective of the figure of people ” . Mr Jindal planned to follow his Salboni theoretical account in other provinces like Jharkhand, Rajasthan & A ; Andhra Pradesh.

The JSW group had other expansive programs to do this a successful land acquisition. It entered into partnership with a Kolkata based Business school ( ICFAI Business School ) . They roped in this group to fix a preparation faculty for 5000 uneven households in Salboni & A ; bordering small towns to do them occupation ready. JSW Steel will bear the cost of the preparation of the employable members which is likely to be imparted by the ITIs ( Industrial Training Institutes ) of West Bengal.

Out of the 5000 estates of land acquired by the undertaking merely 500 estates was acquired by the Jindals straight while the remainder 4500 estates were acquired by the West Bengal Government. JSW has fixed the monetary value for the private land in Salboni at INR 0.25 million to INR 0.3 million per acre. The land has been categorized as arable and partially arable and priced consequently. The monetary value of the authorities land is INR 0.194 million per acre as per Land and Land Reforms Department.

Unfortunately things are non every bit rose-colored as the media & A ; the West Bengal authorities would believe us to believe. Despite the attempts of media to go through off this land acquisition as a really successful one & A ; the beginning of a “ new industrial revolution ” in West Bengal things are far from world. The Indian Express reported on June 12th 2007 that Farmers are looking frontward to the land acquisition. “ Unlike the landholders of Singur, a subdivision of whom are unwilling to portion with their retentions despite a good compensation bundle, Salboni ‘s husbandmans are woolgathering of going stockholders as the Jindals have promised a compensation bundle that includes hard currency for the land, portions in the new company against the value of the land and a occupation for each household ” . Attempts were put in to go through the land as wholly barren & A ; a glandular fever harvest land. Even today many bookmans attribute Jindal ‘s successful land acquisition to the fact that the land was barren & As ; non suit for agribusiness. That ‘s over simplification of the state of affairs. “ The land here sustains merely one harvest a twelvemonth, sometimes two, depending on rains. The chief harvests are sesame ( til ) , murphy and mustard, together with some Paddy ”

However this undertaking has been indefinitely delayed. For the last four old ages the Jindal ‘s have been puting up this green field steel undertaking. No work has started yet. And after the JSW group have Ispat in their pool the work would non get down so early. Most experts say that a green field steel undertaking is one of the most hard things to get down. Even heavy weights like Lakshmi Mittal have burnt their fingers. Furthermore what started as a Steel undertaking all of a sudden got converted into a “ SEZ ” – a Particular Economic Zone. After the Singur episode affecting Tata Nano and the atrociousnesss in Nandigram by the Left Front over a chemical zone, anything tagged ‘SEZ ‘ , ‘industrialisation ‘ , ‘land acquisition ‘ or ‘Left Front ‘ raised the intuitions of people. No work has started yet, and so there are no promised occupations. What has happened is that rather a 1000 of people have lost their farming areas. In the range of the current province elections around 2011 both the West Bengal Government & A ; the JSW would lie low. Work can get down merely after June 2011 likely after a new CM takes over Bengal.

The Rehabilitation and Settlement Bill and the Land Acquisition ( Amendment ) Bill were tabled in the Parliament in 2008. One of its nucleus proposals was the authorities should non be a direct participant in land acquisition for industries. This raised a immense chromaticity & A ; call in the corporate media. ABP group, one of the largest media houses in West Bengal complained & A ; cried hoarse. The ABP group complained that the gait of industrialisation would decelerate down in provinces where persons are proprietors of little secret plans of lands. Therefore the industrialist would confront much trouble in geting a large amalgamate piece of land which is needed for big graduated table industries. On the one manus, land monetary value would hit up due to inefficiency in the land market. On the other, powerful speculators would get down naming the shootings. Hence the existent proprietor of the land would lose out every bit good. This could hold been avoided had the province authorities acquired the land.

Rajesh Gupta, Project Vice President, JSW Bengal, thinks Panchayats have four major functions to play. One, to determine who the existent proprietor of the land is. Two, if she is non alive, to observe who is the heir. Three, to make up one’s mind who will acquire what part of the compensation. Four, to clear up the nature of the bundle offered by the company to the villagers. In West Bengal unluckily there is really small difference between the Panchayats & A ; the “ Party ” . So the disposal & A ; the political party become synonymous. Certain villagers are of the sentiment that the Panchayat as a bargaining organic structure has taken the side of the Jindals alternatively of back uping their cause.

In these small towns there was no resistance party. One major ground that the CPI ( M ) could travel away with this trade was because that the Trinamul had no presence in those countries. Villagers were non consulted in repairing the land monetary value. The Land Revenue Department calculates it on the footing of the mean prevalent monetary value of old three old ages. “ Therefore Rs. 2.75 hundred thousand and Rs. 3 lakhs per acre for non-agricultural and agricultural land are the right monetary values. ” While land monetary value in Singur was 8-9 hundred thousand per acre these people think they got a natural trade. More over multi harvest land has been passed off as glandular fever harvest waste land. Once the mill starts the surrounding small towns would hold a scarceness of irrigation H2O & A ; imbibing H2O.

Environmental effects have non been considered. Cipher has taken into history what happens when the land H2O would foul by the surrounding industry.

Nothing has been promised to the share-croppers. Even amazing is the low figure of portion sharecrop farmers in the Official history. There are merely 28 portion sharecrop farmers noted in the registry. The sum of money that has been given would non pay the involvement to run a household. Jobs have been promised one time the mill comes up. So far there has been no development.

A Fact happening mission by a group called Sanhati gives a first-hand study of the Jindal SEZ at Salboni.

Their findings include

“ The undertaking has been given the SEZ position by maintaining the land givers and whole of West Bengal in dark. The conditions/treaty of the province authorities with the Jindals has been kept in dark.

The tribal people ‘s land has been illicitly transferred.

By giving premier land and forest country to the Jindals, the tribal and backward-class people have been stripped of their rights to water-land-forest.

The pattadars have non received any compensation to this twenty-four hours

The Salboni land is non bare. In fact, with proper irrigation strategy, one-crop/two-crop land can be converted to multi-crop land.

The hapless tribal and people from backward category will go even poorer.

The country environing the undertaking will be inhospitable. In future, hapless tribal and backward category people have to go forth their native land.

There has been no agreement sing portions and rente, hence at that place has been fiscal agony among land givers.

The hapless and illiterate people from the country have no hope sing employment, and they think they will non acquire the occupations

The environment of the forest land and environing country will endure serious harm due to pollution from mill

The whole country will confront acute H2O scarceness. There will be terrible harm to the environing rivers. ”

Swati Bhattacharrya in Anandabazaar Patrika has concluded that Salboni villagers have missed three cherished chances. One, they have non been able to joint their demands over compensation bundle. Two, they could non obtain any infrastructural installation. Three, for their hereafter support and life they have now become dependant on the charity of industrialists. This may take them to the opposite pole of capableness. “ Amartya Sen remarked that a hapless individual is one whose likings or dislikings have no value. Industrialisation is repeating this truth. The concluding inquiry is hence on end and agencies. If the intent of development is remotion of poorness, authorising the vulnerable, can it be achieved through a procedure which is against societal justness? ”

Bangalore Mysore Infrastructure corridor ( BMIC ) issue

The 6 lane freeway was conceived for building between Bangalore and Mysore in 1988 with the following two aims

Connecting these turning metropoliss with the freeway

Developing the township around the freeway

The undertaking was awarded by the province authorities of Karnataka to Nandi Infrastructure Corridor Enterprises Ltd. ( NICE ) , a particular purpose vehicle constructed for this intent. The undertaking was awarded on dialogue footing after competitory command failed. While making the feasibleness survey for this undertaking bing 2000 crores on Build Own Operate and Transfer ( BOOT ) footing, NICE came up with proposal of seven townships building which were subsequently scaled down to five townships building by the authorities.

The undertaking succeeded in acquiring necessary blessings from SPCB ( particular intent building board ) in August, 2000. In the twelvemonth 2001, it got clearance from MoEF every bit good.

Land Acquisition Plan

Of 20,193 estates of land required, merely 4,628 estates was under the authorities which consisted of waste land and woods land. The private land consisted of waste land, rain fed land and irrigated land for agribusiness and land under the gardens. This was supposed to luxate 1500 farming households straight and indirectly 200,000 individuals.

Harmonizing to Government policy, the land acquisition was supposed to be subsidized by the authorities by supplying authorities land at 10 Rs per acre. Equally far as land of husbandmans was concerned, there was no just market value rating of their land and therefore their land was supposed to be earnestly undervalued. The husbandmans had reserves about change overing their extremely irrigable land for the building of townships.

Resettlement and Rehabilitation

The subdivision on R & A ; R in environmental impact appraisal ( EIA ) does n’t supply for compensation of any losingss incurred by the community. In fact, the undertaking was conceived with a premiss that it will heighten the development of the part. However, no believable grounds has been at that place sing how such development be assessed. Further, the subdivision was mute about how this economic development would assist the displaced people.

Environmental Concerns


The undertaking had issues with the conservationists. Purportedly, 2968 estates of Badamanavarthi Kaval forests in the urban territories of the Bangalore part were required to be destroyed for the building of the freeway. In add-on to this, 4075 estates of the Handigundi and the Chikkamanagude forest screen of rural part of Bangalore were besides required to be swept. Since these were among the really few staying natural woods, conservationists had serious concerns with the undertaking. It was alleged that it would badly destruct the vegetations and zoologies of the part and the species populating therein. Surprisingly, there was no reference of the impact of the undertaking on the environment in the study submitted by NICE in the populace.


Besides, the completion of undertaking required NICE to utilize about 150 MLD of H2O ( about 25 % of the supply to Bangalore part ) . This would interrupt the H2O supply of the metropolis. Besides, BMIC was supposed to acquire 85 MLD of waste H2O for non-potable intent. This would impact husbandmans badly who use this H2O for irrigation of their land. This prompted Bangalore Water Supply and Sewage Board ( BWSS ) to decline shifting of H2O and sewerage grapevines which was indispensable for completion of the undertaking in the needed signifier. Subsequently in 2008, on the orders of the High Court of Karnataka, BWSS was directed to switch the H2O and sewerage grapevines for BMIC undertaking.

Lakes and Tanks

There were apprehensivenesss sing devastation of 8 lakes in the locality of the corridor. The corridor would bisect Gottigere Lake which is ecologically of import unrecorded armored combat vehicle. If this lake is killed, it will lose an of import beginning of H2O.

Religious Concerns

Some of the supplication halls were located in the manner of the proposed route. Therefore, the authorities had to switch some of these edifices elsewhere and in some instances route alliance had to be modified to avoid aching spiritual colonies.

Judicial Intervention

Some of the clearances were rapidly achieved because of the judicial activism particularly that of higher tribunals. The land acquisition Torahs were appropriately altered at times to hasten the advancement of the undertaking.

Other Concerns

Some of the above concerns were related to the transparence of the undertaking. The undertaking was awarded on negotiation footing in the first topographic point alternatively of competitory command due to really few participants offering for the undertaking. Besides, it was alleged that some of the functionaries of BMIC were employed by NICE after they retired from their office in the province. This raised the inquiries on unity of these functionaries. Besides, there was deficiency of transparence related to the rating of the private land.

Further, the demand of the land to be acquired maintain on changing during the class of the undertaking. One ground for this could be that land demand was planned by NICE and the authorities did n’t look into the sanctioned drawings. Therefore, there was possibility of geting the land for some politicians or other parties holding vested involvements.


The undertaking was delayed due to miss of transparence at assorted phases. Environmental and set down acquisition appraisals were done by the advisers based on field studies. This had expostulations from the societal militants chiefly because there was a considerable clip spread between these appraisals and awarding of the undertaking due to which the land conditions change. Enterprises to hasten the appraisal should be made. For this advanced engineering could be used like orbiter imagination to estimate the figure of people who would be affected.

The land was acquired by the District Collector based on the cast responsibility charged. This resulted in underpricing of the land. Therefore, efforts should be made to hold statute laws in topographic point for just rating of the land. Finally, decentalisation at the province degree would assist in faster determination devising by cut downing the figure of bureaus required for blessing.