Chanakya And His Influence On Modern Day Espionage History Essay

Chanakya And His Influence On Modern Day Espionage History Essay

Chanakya, more conspicuously known as “ Kautilya ” , was one of the greatest philosophers, minds and tacticians, non merely India, but the universe itself had of all time seen. This “ Indian Machiavelli ” , ironically, who was outstanding before the times of Niccollo Machiavelli himself, had carved himself a topographic point among the greats of Socrates, Aristotle and so on and so forth. But, despite of his important parts towards the psyche of many fundamental laws, his tactics and policies being used and abused by many a swayers to do or interrupt a province with the aid of atomic warfare and low profile blackwashs, what the common adult male tends to lose is the nexus between the headlines of today ‘s universe and the encephalon kid of an rational, who had one time laid the foundation of one of the mightiest empires the Common Era had of all time seen, the Magadha Empire under his pupil and emperor, Chandraguptha Maurya. This leads any funny head to a inquiry, as to what had helped the imperium of Magadha asseverate its place as one of the most dominant imperiums, be it on quantum of economic stableness or military strength, of that epoch. The reply had ever lied right in forepart of us. A closer analysis of today ‘s crisis and their redresss and its mention and comparing to Chanakya ‘s work, the “ Arthashastra ” , unearths the roots of modern political and economic events, to the deepnesss of an epoch existent before Jesus Christ himself. No affair how deep history attempts to bury his parts with the littorals of of all time altering modern confederacies and patterned advance, Kautilya will stay to be one among the greatest political originators, who has doubtless contributed a batch to what we, our recent fore-fathers, and the coevalss to come, name, called and will name, ” our modern universe ” .


This research is done with an aim to find whether the modus operandi of modern espionage bureaus of assorted provinces working across the universe has, if, of all time implemented the tactics and policies, on how such an organisation should be runing, prescribed by the great Indian instructor, Chanakya, besides known as Kautilya, in his work, the “ Arthashastra ” . This research chiefly focuses on look intoing the credibleness and practicality of his tactics and policies in the field of espionage, with regard to the present universe scenario. This comparing and analysis is fundamentally done with an purpose to reply any inquiry, which attempts to organize a relationship, furthermore a nexus, between Chanakya ‘s thoughts about espionage and covert operations and the modern screenshot of the latter two. The research worker has done his research with the interlingual rendition of the “ Arthashastra ” as the base and has farther relied on assorted online every bit good as print media for the completion of this analytical comparing.

Before one may leap directly onto comparing the analytical consequences of few incidents around today ‘s universe with that of the political orientations of the great mind Kautilya, one may take an involvement in cognizing more about who Kautilya, or known better by the name Chanakya, as a individual was. The beginnings of this great originator has ne’er met the existent beams of Sun. But his presence throughout the aureate epoch of Indian history had been inscribed in about every available text from that epoch, both foreign and domestic.

Chanakya had a cardinal function in the rise of Chandraguptha Maurya as the swayer of the mighty Magadhan imperium, and that excessively at the immature old ages of the emperor. Chanakya ‘s thoughts and doctrines is what was believed to set up and asseverate the power of Magadha as one of the strongest imperiums of that epoch, and an Indian imperium which could give any other civilisation a great competition in footings of economic prosperity every bit good as the toughness and strength of its ground forces and the efficiency of its intelligence web. Chanakya, non merely emphasized in his work, Arthashastra, to set up a land where there was no political corruptness or instability, no economic insecurity, but besides where the menaces from any enemy swayers, moves against the emperor, both internal and external efforts could be foiled in an efficient and effectual mode, without the eruption of any contentions. It is on this peculiar facet of his work, his return on the function and map of espionage, in set uping a strong imperium and interrupting one that of an enemy, and how his work is interpreted and implemented to accommodate the modern epoch of planetary warfare by todays swayers. For this survey to be good, one must be cognizant of the tactics and methods of operation of espionage organisations in the Magadha imperium under the programs laid down by Chanakya himself.

The covert operations flying under the supervising of Chanakya was really much sophisticated, yet efficient in nature. After the assignment of the imperial curates, the following of import occupation for the male monarch was to enroll his a dependable web of undercover agents, both to maintain an oculus on the curate every bit good as to poke at any moves against the emperor, both internally and externally with regard to the imperiums territorial legal power.

The responsibilities of these undercover agents covered Acts of the Apostless of describing the rumours being spread around by people, good or bad, about the emperor ; intelligence and rumours being spread about the emperor in the adjacent states ; listen in on programs of onslaught and other political schemes to derive an upper-hand on the Magadhan imperium by the enemy swayers ; to tormenting and pull outing valuable information from the enemy ‘s generals ; to discreetly assassinate high functionaries of the Magadhan imperium, who are found to be corrupt ; every bit good as high administrative officials of enemy provinces ; make political confusion in other provinces to derive an upper-hand over the enemy province while the emperor is presenting an onslaught, and so on and so forth. The undercover agent web is loosely categorized into two chief headers, one would be that of the agents stationed in one topographic point, metropolis, town etc. , while the other would be that of agents who travel around from one topographic point to another in hunt of information that could be of good to the patterned advance of the province every bit good as really much important to the security of the imperiums unity every bit good as endurance.

On how the secret service is to be formed, Chanakya prescribes that it is the duty of the male monarch to do the possible campaigners undergo through seven trials of trueness. Any information validated through three undercover agents shall be accepted as the truth while if any undercover agent was found inefficient or his intelligence faithlessly, so he or she badly be executed. The intelligent officer should be a individual of high intelligence, crisp head and brave with un-doubtable trueness to the emperor and his fatherland. For his heroism and trueness, backed up with his efficient operations, he shall be rewarded by the emperor suitably for is services.

Screens used by agents:

The undercover agents, station both within and outside the political boundaries of the imperium, blend in with the people by using screen like that of a monastic, a house holder, bargainer or an ascetic. The agents are provided with sufficient resources, so that they can take up a screen of their pick, accommodating the demand of the hr and the advantages which can be perchance gained if such a screen is undertaken. So far was merely about the stationed agents. The rolling agents takes up the functions of Assassin, Poisoner and rolling nuns. Assassins are normally the most brave in the land, who are normally soldier of fortunes who are willing to set their life in the line of fire for gaining a few Nis. While the poisoners, on the other manus are fundamentally people who show m=no clemency or any marks of kindness to any being around him.

Transmission of intelligence:

The intelligence collected by the undercover agents are all collected and transmitted through different agencies. The sender will non hold any thought who the gatherers are, and nor will they have any hint as to what the message contains. They make certain that the message is encrypted in such a manner that merely the receiving system can decode it and set it into the needed manner of action so as to ease the smooth and safe operation of the authorities. They may be in the signifiers of vocals, address, symbols or other coded words like topographic point names with Numberss, names of goods and trade goods, of import ranks etc. in the absence of couriers, the agents who are assigned to a peculiar station might do alibis like being ailing, wellness wise, or any exigency had arisen at their hometown or places, so that they can acquire out of the Stationss and straight convey their messages to the needed senior officers to take farther actions sing the intelligence.

At times, alternatively of deploying agents of their ain inside the edifices of the enemy male monarchs and possible enemies of the province, Chanakya besides says that one can change over an bing functionary in the needed zone to be an plus of the emperor. These functionaries possibly corrupt curate in the enemies council, generals of the ground forcess of the enemy male monarchs, or the staff of curate of the curates of the emperor. To command their trueness, it is advised that the households and loved 1s of the dual agent might be held surety so that the dual agent will work more unfeignedly and efficaciously so as to salvage the lives of his loved 1s. Agents may besides be deployed to detect the operations of the swayers of enemy district, by taking up the screens of domestic aid inside the houses of the enemy generals and curates, bargainers and merchandisers in the metropoliss, husbandmans in the small towns and mobile herders in the frontiers. Forest inhabitants were besides used to maintain an oculus on enemy operation across the boundary line, and they were rewarded for map expeditiously on executing their assigned responsibilities.

Counter espionage:

It was non sufficient merely to hold an effectual undercover agent web to maintain an oculus on the activities of the enemies of the province, harmonizing to Chanakya. In-fact, the province should besides run a parallel web of espionage, which could forestall enemy undercover agents from roll uping of import informations from within the imperium. To blow the enemy operatives cover, the male monarch might take stairss like delegating undercover agents of great quality and really low profile to look into into such affairs, station presenting an act of disloyalty among the councilors so as to pull the enemy undercover agents and take advantage of the attendant state of affairs.

The undercover agents, both in espionage and counter-espionage wings, may take up camouflages of a assortment of picks, out of which the most outstanding 1s would be cart driver, juggler, fortune Teller, forecaster, cocotte, whorehouse keeper, rich widow, craftsman, histrion, physician, doctor, moonstruck, physically impaired individual, merchandiser baker, astrologist and so on and so forth.

It is surprising to cognize being cognizant of the fact that Kautilya had spent his whole life-time in India, the modern twenty-four hours espionage organisation, the research and analysis wing, has non implemented any of Chanakya ‘s tactics in the manner of operations. Keeping that idea, if one was to measure the developments in the espionage field across the universe, it may be found that the foreign authoritiess are really moving in conformity to what the Indian bookman planned for set uping a full efficient authorities. Few of the most efficient intelligence wings across would be the cardinal intelligence bureau of the united provinces of America, supported by their covert operations military wing, and the Secret intelligence service, more conspicuously known as the mi6 and its sister units in Britain, the Mossad of Israel, reputed for bring forthing one of the most efficient bravos across the Earth, and the Sluzhba Vneshney Razvedki and its sister units in Russia.

The American intelligence wing:

The espionage bureau of America fundamentally comes under the bid of the Cia, which straight reports to the president. The intelligence assemblage is done by this organisation, while its blackwash responsibilities are executed by their ain trained secret agents. At times, these same responsibilities are outsourced to the covert operations units of the armed forces within the state, or of foreign states. The covert op units of the united provinces armed forces includes the us navy seals, the delta force unit and so on and so forth.

The efficiency of the united provinces espionage could be observed on taking 2, among the many allegedly available incidents, in the history. One of the m being the blackwash of the one time labeled universe ‘s most wanted terrorist, Osama bin Laden, at his secret abode in Abbottabad, in Pakistan. The intelligence with respect to his whereabouts were non available to any of the other states, non even its stopping points neighbour and the one neighbour with whom the state has strong political tenseness, India. The Cia gathered this intelligence, allegedly, through a physician who had been on a regular basis sing the sign of the zodiac in which laden had been utilizing as his safe house. The more surprising fact, in this instance if one may be bias towards the united provinces ‘ claims, is that, the intelligence bureau was so efficient in bring outing the whereabouts of this international terrorist, who had found his safe-house in a hot spot for seditious issues, and that excessively merely a few 100 stat mis off from the province ‘s capital metropolis. it is besides to be noted that despite the screen provided by the Pakistan authorities, who was one time, and still is an ally of the us govt. , and the safe-house being really next to a Pak ground forces base cantonment, the us had still managed to unearth the hideaway and send in particular forces to infiltrate into the compound, and successfully finishing the executing of the mark. The agencies by which they entered the hostile district, without puting off any dismay in the Pak intelligence radio detection and ranging, is besides a looming grounds of the efficiency of their intelligence wing. But on taking a closer expression at this whole event, it can be established that what the united provinces authorities and what Chanakya had prescribed in Arthashastra are both in one sense really similar. The deployment of undercover agents, the blackwash of the mark, the manner of operation etc. , are all really much similar.

The Mossad.

The Mossad is yet another deathly intelligence bureau known across the universe for bring forthing the few among the finest and most unmerciful bravos in the universe. The Israeli secret service had been really discreet in its activities every bit good as covert operations, both within its districts every bit good as outside it. One of the recent occurrences which could bespeak the presence of their undercover agents throughout the universe would be that of the blackwash, or instead executing of Muhammed Suleiman, the Syrian president, Bashar al-Assad ‘s particular presidential adviser for weaponries procurance and strategic arms. Suleiman was shot to decease, allegedly by a Mossad secret agent. The studies states that agencies of executing was by agencies of sniping the mark and the bravo had fled with the aid of a boat. The agency of flight was chosen with regard to the easiness of flight every bit good as the place and modus operandi by which the mark had moved into the hot-zone, which was in Suleiman ‘s instance, his walk along the coast side of the beach.

This is one more, among the many other illustrations as to how the modern universe has adopted the tactics of Chanakya to deploy undercover agents and assassinate of import very important persons of the enemy swayer by closely detecting the marks and placing the cringle holes in their modus operandis and using them to the benefit of the bravo every bit good as the province.

Modern twenty-four hours Indian scenario and Chanakya.

In the present India, the intelligence wing has been divided into two chief subdivision, one the Intelligence Bureau, which deals domestic intelligence and counter intelligence maps of the intelligence wing, and the Research and Analysis Wing, which deals with the external intelligence personal businesss of the state. Despite holding the political orientations of a great philosopher like Chanakya himself to our rich and outstanding political heritage, the modern Indian functionaries and Governors has failed to implement an jury-rigged version of the great instructor ‘s tactics of espionage in the present twenty-four hours scenario, which would hold been of great usage to continuing the stableness and security of the province as a state, non yielding to any kinds of menaces from both internal and external forces, if it had been implemented decently. Unlike its western and much advanced opposite numbers, the Research and Analysis Wing has no recorded important accomplishments or successful covert operations to tout about other than a few contentions and corruptness charges against its functionaries, like any other politically governed organic structure in India. Mixing Kautilya ‘s thoughts of a perfect province with clay, the present Indian scenario depicts the image of the Indian intelligence service every bit merely another organic structure which corrupt politicians of both the place and foreign states use to their ain personal dockets or puting foundation to another international contentions. One may besides observe that the perennial figure of bombardments and terrorist onslaughts that had happened in the metropolitan metropoliss across the state itself is a looming index as to how inefficient is the present twenty-four hours descry web under the modern Indian authorities. But, one may besides claim that the same deficiency of bright records could be a portion of being a extremely efficient intelligence organisation. Yet given the image of the present scenario of Indian intelligence, an person may state that it is high clip they stop doing Torahs and get down interrupting a few, so that they could do an effectual, every bit good as a deathly web of undercover agents and bravos, so that they can assist their state survive through any concealed every bit good as exposed and exploited crisis, and guarantee the failure of the enemies of the province.


Bing made aware of the similarities of the operation of Chanakya ‘s theoretical account of an espionage system and the system of present universe scenario prevelant in different provinces, one may reason that Chanakya has vastly contributed towards the constitution of effectual undercover agent webs throughout the universe. Though, in today ‘s universe, espionage and counter espionage is really much related to national security and extinguishing the menaces to the same, in the worm ‘s oculus position ; one may look at the same from a broader position to happen that it has partly succeeded in doing the universe a better, or as one may state, a safer topographic point to populate in, for the common adult male. But an person may besides non pretermit the blatant truth that the same espionage webs and their operations are slightly, or is alleged to be, clandestinely responsible for doing tenseness, or even worse, break outing wars among two or more provinces. Furthermore, the more they make people experience secure about today ‘s universe, the more they tend to make strenuous relationships among the provinces throughout. But, every bit far as Chanakya ‘s political orientation of the being an effectual intelligence and counter intelligence organic structure for a province is concerned, the research worker may reason that most of the provinces across the Earth has succeeded in set uping efficient clandestine webs, which lives up-to he had portrayed in his work, as an efficient web.